Michael Myers Squishmallow Review: A 6.5-Inch Halloween II Plush

At 6 1/2 inches tall, this Michael Myers Squishmallow finds a neat balance between horror character and cuddly shelf companion. The contrast is the appeal: Jazwares turns the silent figure from Halloween 2 (1981) into a rounded, soft plush, then preserves enough of his familiar look to make the character immediately recognizable. The reviewer found it at Five Below in early September and paid $6.

The price and size make this a compact option for collectors who want a Michael Myers item without committing to a larger plush. The source mentions a bigger version, described as around 8 inches tall and wider, but doesn't confirm its availability or whether that version shares the same retailer. This smaller example was found at Five Below; the reviewer suggests it may be a lower-cost store exclusive, while making clear that this isn't confirmed.

A soft shape with a sharp character design

Squishmallows are known for their soft, plump construction, and this one follows the familiar egg-like silhouette. That simple shape could have flattened the character's details. Instead, the stitched features do much of the work: the coveralls, arms, mask, and knife remain distinct despite the toy's rounded proportions. The result leans into the playful side of the format without losing the visual cues that identify Michael Myers.

The mask is the strongest example. Its features are intentionally spare, with dark eyes and a blank expression that suggest the familiar mask rather than attempting a detailed portrait. Small silvery areas near the top add a touch of shading or reflected light. They're subtle details, but they give the face more depth and show care in translating the design onto plush fabric.

There's a fun bit of character-specific contrast in the knife stitched onto the plush. A pumpkin motif might have made an easy seasonal substitute, but the knife keeps this version tied to Michael Myers. It's a small design choice with a clear payoff: even in a cute, soft format, the character's familiar silhouette and accessories carry through.

The back also gets attention. The mask's hairline, the collar and rear pockets of the coveralls, and the elastic waistband are all represented. These details won't dominate a front-facing display, but they make the toy feel considered from more than one angle. For a plush built around a simple shape, that extra stitching gives collectors more to inspect.

Condition check: inspect the stitching

The reviewer spotted one minor flaw: a loose silver thread at the lips. It was more visible in person than in the photograph, and small scissors might be enough to trim it. That note is useful for anyone choosing among store stock. Check the face and other stitched areas under good light, and compare examples if several are available. Loose threads are a finish issue to look for, especially on a piece whose appeal depends on its embroidery and small facial details.

The source doesn't describe special care instructions or provide packaging details. For this example, the practical condition check is straightforward: look closely at the stitching before purchase and make sure the mask, coveralls, and accessories are finished to your liking. The reviewer considered the loose thread minor and remained pleased with the plush overall.

A seasonal find for horror and plush collectors

The reviewer had never owned a Squishmallow before finding this one, though the plushes were already familiar from family and friends. Michael Myers proved persuasive: the soft construction makes him an amusing companion for a horror-movie night, while the character design suits a seasonal display near a candy bowl. The reviewer especially jokes about watching Halloween 2, since that's the film named for this version, but the plush can of course sit in for any entry in the series.

This is a small, accessible character plush rather than a heavily specified collectible release. The source gives its height and the purchase price, but no item number, edition information, or production total. What it does offer is a clear account of the details that make this version work: a recognizable mask, carefully stitched coveralls, a knife, and finishing touches on the back.

For collectors of Michael Myers merchandise, horror toys, or Squishmallows, the attraction is that mix of faithful cues and soft, comic proportions. The reviewer came away delighted with the find and rated it “Great and a 1/2.” Anyone comparing examples in store can focus on the facial stitching and loose threads; those small details are where this design's character really shows.

More of the reviewer's Michael Myers coverage is collected in The Myers House.